To begin with, we will look at the famous Ishikawa diagram, also known as a cause-and-effect or "fishbone" diagram. For our purposes, we are using the eight M’s version, which covers man, material, machine, method, management, measurement, maintenance, and Mother Nature (environment). In this article series, we will not be covering all eight of these elements of designing and manufacturing a silicone component for life sciences. In this article series we will address two of these: the material and the method of manufacture and subsequently their interplay with design and economics. We will cover the balance of these eight M’s in future pieces.
Ishakawa "Fishbone" Diagram: 8Ms of Product Design and Manufacturing
The Chemistry of Silicones
Silicone is a very desired material in the life sciences, as well as other industries. Unlike other synthetic elastomers that are made of hydrocarbons, Silicone is derived from sand (SiO2), water, and natural gas derived methanol. Common organic synthetic elastomer molecules have repeating carbon (C) atoms. The chemistry on the top of the figure below is the chemical structure for synthetic polyisoprene. As can be seen, in the backbone chain, those black elements are carbon-to-carbon (C-C) and there is a carbon-to-carbon (C-C) chain or repeating chain structure, and that is the basis for many synthetic elastomers.
Chemical and Molecular Structure
On the bottom of the figure is the key differentiating characteristic, which is the silicon (Si) and oxygen (O) substituted chain versus that C-C chain of polyisoprene.
Silicone also known polysiloxane is a chain of siloxane bonds (-Si-O-Si-). Organic units are introduced to the silicone molecules to add various characteristics. With two methyl groups attached to the backbone, polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) is the most widely used silicone. The siloxane structure and elements used in the backbone of silicone polymer, enables us to have properties that are unique and very desirous for life science applications.
Siloxane bonds have much greater bond energy compared to C-C bonds, therefore, will not break at temperatures as high as 400°F (200°C) or certain grades up to 575°F (300°C). Silicone polymer molecular structure is highly flexible resulting in low glass transition temperature (Tg). They are, therefore, flexible and functional at negative or freezing temperatures. The hydrophobic methyl groups in the structure are accountable for its water repellency. Silicone elastomers have unique chemical and physical properties with excellent biocompatibility and biodurability and ideal for many life-science applications. Other notable characteristics of silicones are excellent resistance to aging, low extractables, low leachable.
Biocompatibility is one of the desirous characteristics as well as the ability to meet a variety of healthcare and medical industry requirements. Silicones are formulated conveniently to comply with USP Class VI standards and ISO-10993 regulatory requirements which include:
- Compliant with cleanliness requirements, and cGMP requirements.
- Sterilizable with steam (autoclave) or gamma irradiation
- Do not contain latex, organic plasticizers, or phthalates
There are two types of silicones that are frequently considered for life science applications, they are High Consistency Rubber (HCR) silicone and Liquid Silicone Rubber (LSR).